I Don’t Think My Husband is a Good Dad

It’s hard to predict what kind of parent a person is going to be. No matter what kind of assumptions or projections you make, when it comes to actually raising a child, your spouse may not handle things the way you expected at all!

Many couples run into these kinds of disagreements shortly after they have their first child – when they finally start to get used to parenthood, they start critiquing each other’s approach. In most cases (but certainly not all), women have had a little more experience – or at least some informal education – with childcare than men.

When these arguments happen, the common dynamic is the new mother criticizing her husband’s “parenting style.” This doesn’t describe every scenario, of course, but it’s certainly the most common version of this problem

So, what are the arguments actually about? Usually, it comes down to difference of opinion – one parent thinks the child needs all organic food, the other parent doesn’t seem so worried about it; one parent strictly limits the amount of television the child is exposed to, the other uses the TV as a temporary babysitter… or any of a long list of examples.

Do you disagree with your spouse's parenting style?
Do you disagree with your spouse’s parenting style?

But little arguments can happen about anything – a lot of this stuff is just opinion, or reflects different ways of growing up – and that’s exactly where we have to begin if we want to resolve these disagreements. The first step is recognizing what parental approaches are simply different, and what practices are actually wrong.

If the child is in danger, being neglected, or if a parent’s decisions are preventing them from living a happy, healthy life – those are the wrong decisions. But if it’s simply a matter of one meal over another, a negligible amount of TV time, a choice of clothes, or something equally innocuous, it’s not wrong – it’s just different.

Failing to recognize this distinction, and confronting your spouse about their parenting can come across as criticism of their intelligence and an attack on their character. And because many people feel some self-doubt and fear about being a new parent already, they can really take this kind of criticism to heart.

It’s a sensitive issue, where the person on the receiving end of the criticism can feel inadequate, and the person criticizing can skew their own perspective of the person they love. Combine these with the stresses of being a new parent, and it becomes a dangerous mixture of feelings that can severely damage the marriage. Unchecked, this will lead to resentment on both sides.

First, learn to recognize the difference between “different” and “wrong,” and when it comes time to talk about your differences of opinion, remind yourself (and each other that it isn’t a personal attack), it’s concern for the wellbeing of the child.

Even if you continue to disagree, that’s ok! As long as you’re taking care of critical elements like health and safety, a little variation in parenting style isn’t going to hurt anyone.

Sticking with the “typical” version of these issue, some moms will simply have to relax their hold on parenting style, and let dad do things his own way a little bit. And the dads out there will just have to be open to some education and expertise from their wives, their mothers, and the other people in their lives that will likely have some advice to impart.

There’s no absolute, 100% “right” way to raise your children, but letting disagreements create a rift in your marriage is NOT the way to maintain the happy, supportive home that all kids deserve. If you disagree about an element of one another’s parenting, talk about it calmly, and keep the discussion to the activity or attitude in question – don’t let it seep into personal attacks or other criticisms.

For both of you, parenting should be a team effort – so if one of you isn’t thrilled with the other’s approach, it’s up to both of you to resolve the issue. This could be taking classes together, doing some research, consulting with other parents, or anything else that is going to expand your understanding and get the two of you collaborating instead of disagreeing.

There’s one thing you can always count on as the right decision for your child: maintaining a strong, stable relationship that teaches them the importance of love, support, and compromise.

For more advice on how to strengthen your marriage, check out the StrongMarriageNow System today!
Dr. Dana Fillmore and Amy Barnhart, co-Founders, StrongMarriageNow.com

Related Posts

The Importance Of Time Away From The Kids

Parenting is a full-time job. Anyone with kids (especially more than one) will agree that around the clock, children need supervision and care. Even as your kids grow into teens and young adults, they still turn to their parents for guidance, permission, and as you may know all too well, money. But being a parent […]

Protect Your Marriage by Becoming a Good Step-Parent

Coming into an existing family dynamic can be extremely tough – as you surely know if you’ve gone through it. Becoming a step-parent, or having your spouse become the step-parent of your children, isn’t as simple as just getting married – it takes time and effort to develop a relationship with your spouse’s kids, and […]

I’m Worried My New Husband Doesn’t Like My Kids!

We live in a time where second marriages, unmarried parents, and blended families are only becoming more and more common. Unfortunately though, sometimes combining families can cause problems, resentment, unspoken disagreements, and actually drive the would-be family further and further apart.

Dr. Dana Answers Questions on Blended Family Problems

We get all types of questions from married couples across the country (and around the world!), so when we come across one that may be able to help others in need, we can’t help but share it! This question about blended families seemed like perfect opportunity to address an issue that affects many, many second […]


Krystal 9 years ago

My husband easily gets frustrated and annoyed when he has to take care of the kids. Today I woke up with the stupidest cold. I hate being sick. Mainly because I know I am going to be left to deal with the children regardless. My husband is on a two-week vacation from work, and he's been playing his stupid computer game today since the moment he woke up.

lucy 9 years ago

I am beginning to feel like I can't cope with my family situation -- my husband and my son (who is not my husband's biological son, btw) are always arguing and fighting. Not physical fights, but still all the arguing and taunting and whining is beginning to take its toll on me. I am now not even looking forward to going home after work... My son has high functioning autism, so there are behavioral issues. He does see a therapist and I have been going to some of his sessions to talk about family dynamics and how to work with his issues, but I can't get my husband to go with us. My husband doesn't think that he (my husband) is any part of the problem and of course, I know that the whole family has an affect on things but he refuses to admit that.

Mike_Olsen_SMN 9 years ago

Hi Lucy - It's definitely important to try and get him involved, but do what you can if he won't. Try to talk through together about how to handle different scenarios, and when to punish for behavior. https://www.strongmarriagenow.com/important-problem/parenting-yt/

Mike_Olsen_SMN 9 years ago

Hi Krystal - Unfortunately, many spouses, typically men, don't think of children as a 50/50 commitment. It might come down to you telling him that he has to step up to the plate. They are just as must responsibility as yours, and he needs to take care of you as well when he can. https://www.strongmarriagenow.com/important-problem/division-of-labor-yt/

Comments are closed.