Can Separation Save A Marriage?

When you’re struggling in a marriage, it’s perfectly normal to think in terms of direct fixes, of night and day changes in your situation, when in reality relationships don’t change that instantaneously. And while it may be frustrating to hear, the answers to specific “what should I do” questions are often much, much broader than a set course of action.

We recently received a question from one subscriber on the cusp of separating from his wife.

Alan asks:

“I’ve been married 17 years, but now my wife wants a divorce. She is seeing someone
else, although she insists they are just friends, but she has admitted to ‘strong feelings’
for the other guy. She wants to start the clock ticking on separation, and has asked me
to consider several options for future living arrangements – which would mean me
moving out. I said I would consider her suggestions, but that was really to buy some
time. My intention is NOT to move. My feeling is if she wants to start the separation, it
is up to here to initiate any action. Is that the best way to approach this horrible situation? She says her remaining in the home with our two children (14 and 16) is the
best option for them. She seems to think she gets the house, my income, the children,
and the new guy. I believe by saying I won’t move out, I will provoke a bitter and nasty
exchange – but I think this is a place where I need to make a stand, and that it will give
her something to think about. Thoughts?”

Separation may seem like the only choice, but you always have options!
Separation may seem like the only choice, but you always have options!

It certainly sounds like there are multiple issue at work here, from the emotional affair with another man to looming separation and demands about the house, custody, finances, etc., but Alan’s wife asking him to look for new places to live is a symptom, not the problem.

Even what appears to be an emotional affair is a symptom of disconnection in the marriage, and all of the other problems stem directly from that. Instead of playing into the “battle” and refusing to move out, this may be an ideal scenario to take a step back and look at what led to this conflict in the first place.

It’s very clear that Alan doesn’t want his marriage to end, nor does he want to be displaced from his home. His unique scenario, however, raises an opportunity for a lesson applicable to many marriages, no matter how they might be struggling.

When faced with an opportunity for conflict, like Alan’s temptation to “make a stand,” there’s also an opportunity to shift the conversation in a very different direction. Instead of refusing to move out of the house in a confrontational sort of
way, explain that moving out (and the separation/divorce that it entails) is not at all what you want, and that you’re ready and willing to explore the underlying issues that have led you to this point.

It’s not about making a stand, but more about introducing the conversation that could lead to improvement.

If Alan’s wife is willing to give him time to consider a move, she may also be willing to give the idea of separating some time as well. As we’ve said before, it’s entirely possibly to improve a marriage even if only one member is willing to work on it. This situation is no different. You can give your spouse “something to think about” in a non-confrontational way, and it’s likely to be a far more productive conversation than defensive refusal to cooperate.

It comes down to this: anger and harsh actions usually do little but lead to more anger and more problems. To make positive progress, look for opportunities to slow down the procession of arguments and conflict by stripping away the anger and personal hurt, and talking openly about how BOTH of your behavior has caused such a rift in your marriage. Do everything in your power to remain calm and objective – and ask that your spouse do the same.

Alan is right that his situation presents an opportunity to give his wife something to think about, but it’s really an opportunity for them to both address problems and look for a fresh start – before things get worse than they already are.

Is separation is unavoidable, it should be done in a way that allows you to still work on the marriage – instead of a stepping stone to divorce. In fact, it should give you a sense of why it’s better to be with your spouse than without them. It should be a last-ditch, “hail mary” attempt at hitting your marriage’s “reset” button, but if it happens in the midst of anger and hasty decision-making, you’re unlikely to work through the problems.

When you’re facing this kind of marital crossroads, slow down. Don’t make hasty decisions that will affect the rest of your life. Instead, make it your mission to have the tough talks you’ve been putting off, and don’t let anger or stubbornness get in the way of your chance at the healthy, strong marriage you’ve always wanted.

For more advice on how to strengthen your marriage, check out the StrongMarriageNow System today!
Dr. Dana Fillmore and Amy Barnhart, co-Founders,

Related Posts

Will Divorce Really Harm Your Kids?

Divorce can wreak havoc on many parts of life. It’s expensive and time consuming, can drag up painful memories, cause bitter confrontation, bring about financial ruin, damage friendships, and of course, lead to chaos and confusion in the lives of the children whose parents are splitting. But just how severely are these kids affected? We […]

Don’t Be This SCARY Marriage Statistic

Perhaps you’ve heard before that January is “divorce month” – and it’s true! Statistically speaking, the beginning of the year sees a huge spike in divorce filings, and many attorneys report the same experience. Why January? Well, one of the largest possible reasons can be found in the stress of the holidays – and in […]

Who Has It Harder In a Divorce? Men or Women?

Is the dissolution of a romantic relationship harder on men or women? It’s hard to say exactly who has it “worse,” but there’s evidence to suggest that men take divorce especially hard. A recent study published by the Journal of Men’s Health showed that recently divorced men were much more likely to engage in drug […]

3 More Potential Marriage Enders – Part 3

In our final installment of this series, we’ll examine three more problems that can mean catastrophe for your marriage – IF they are allowed to continue unchecked. These are the types of issues that many couples simply accept as “normal,” and allow them to chip away at the quality of the relationship without taking steps […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Mr misunderstood 10 years ago

My wife did move out.. I found out later that originaly she wanted me to move out. That wasnt going to happen. Be happy shes still with you its much easier to work on it that way. Improve yourself, find out what you need to do to fix yourself, and do it consistantly. Im well on my way in the improving myself prosses and though shes not back she does notice and our relationship is getting better and better, its now mostly an issue of trust that i need to earn. I never cheated or was phisically abusive there were big issues with her youth ( abused) and i have known that for 26 years but i didnt act approperatly

Mike_Olsen_SMN 10 years ago

Hi, Mr - Though times are still hard, I'm happy to hear you both are moving in the direction of reconciliation.

waiting 10 years ago

I don't want to fight. Been there done that, just want to distance myself the best that I can and then when I KNOW for sure that I am ready to leave, leave. I guess some of you would call me a WAW because he sits over in la la land and ignores all of the signs. But whatever.

Russty247 10 years ago

my wife has moved out for three months she was having an affair with another man physically for over a year and id say emotionally for possibly two 1/2 to three years. Despite confronting her several times she insisted they were just friends. Eventually he told his wife after being confronted and she told me and our sons 14 & 16 only after thinking they would find out through the grape vine. call me crazy but i would still like to reconcile the marriage for me and the boys and also my wife. She insists she loves me but is happier with the other man. I now find she blames me for the split up and invents or exaggerates things like verbal abuse etc. Her mother died about six years ago and she has shut me out emotionally for pretty much all that time. we started to get marriage counseling. She lied through the first session and then the truth came out. The boys live with me full time and only go to her home once a week for dinner. They refuse to stay over her place. Naturally they don't want to see him at all and of course that goes for me as well. To be perfectly honest the way she has behaved and treated me my family and some friends disgusts me but we had a loving marriage for 18 years and a difficult one for the last six. Unfortunately she still refuses to discuss anything. any advise?

Mike_Olsen_SMN 10 years ago

Hi, waiting - I hope that instead of forcing yourself apart from your husband, you work on pulling you both together.

Mike_Olsen_SMN 10 years ago

Hi, Russty - It's going to be a difficult path to save your marriage. I would suggest reading some advice on surviving an affair - - and our recent advice on whether you should give her a second change.